Painted on the Tank
Starting September 18th, 2026. The strangest high school nicknames in America, and why they exist. At the end you help decide who takes the title of best HS nickname in the country. The winning school gets bragging rights, and $1,000!
View the bracket:
https://bracket.paintedonthetank.com
Painted on the Tank
8. Sleepy Hollow Headless Horsemen
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
You've heard the short story by Washington Irving, now listen about the town and school that proudly bares the nickname of Headless Horsemen!
Good Friday, everyone. I'm Chris Rowland, your host for Painted on the Tank. It is November 6, 2026. Today's episode is number eight on the season, and it involves the sleepy hollow headless horseman. That's right. There is a headless horseman mascot. They're located in the state of New York. But before we get to that, just a reminder of what this podcast is about. It's a search of 32 schools, some of the best nicknames in high school sports in America. And we're trying to advance those week by week. Every other week we have a tournament style voting to where we move a team on to the next round. The winner of this matchup between Sleepy Hollow and Salem from last week will move on to the suite 16 of our tournament. And in the end, in May, we'll crown one champion who you, the listeners, vote for and have deemed as the best nickname in high school sports in America. That'll be the month of May, and that'll feature a $1,000 cash prize as well. So, first of all, the town or the village of Sleepy Hollow. It's located in the town of Mount Pleasant in Westchester County, New York. It's featured on the banks of the Hudson River, approximately 30 miles to the north of Manhattan. And the town originally was incorporated as North Terrytown in the late 19th century. It had success during the Industrial Revolution, which we'll talk a little bit about here shortly. But in 1996, the current name of the village was adopted. The name changed from North Terrytown to Sleepy Hollow. It's internationally known as, though, in reference back to the legend of Sleepy Hollow, the short story by Washington Irving. The population today, it's estimated to be somewhere just under 10,000. As in 2010, the U.S. Census, there was a count of 9,870. Now let's revisit the name North Terrytown. As I mentioned to you earlier, this was the original name of the village. It would later be changed in 1996. But North Terrytown, New York was an industrial hub in the early 1900s, and it stayed that way for many decades. It actually was kick-started with General Motors around 1915 when they constructed a large plant there that would just continue to be added on to as time and its decades went on. It became an employer for many people there in North Terrytown. Now, besides GM, you also had the Hudson River Railroad, which was a supply method of goods to and from the city. You also had the North Terrytown Duracell plant that was on located on Elm Street, a battery manufacturing facility, Duracell, that we're all familiar with. And besides those, you had multiple other smaller factories that would come throughout time and provide employment during that industrial revolution and during a time when North Terrytown citizens were looking for work, and they were very fortunate for many decades to have places of opportunity that many places across the country at that time did not have. So unfortunately, North Terrytown was not immune to the decline in manufacturing jobs that we saw in the 1970s, the mid-70s, when the United States experienced a recession. The Duracell factory managed to stay open until 1984, but the other smaller factories began to close, jobs became more scarce, and the final really big blow as far as manufacturing goes happened in 1996 when the North Terrytown Assembly for GM closed their doors. The last vehicle was rolled off the line in June of that year. And it at that time it concluded the run of the longest continuously operating manufacturing facility in the GM family. And so it was that upon the closure of many of these factories and seeing the industrial side of North Terrytown take a hit. Leaders in the community began to explore ideas about other ways to embrace their town, try to promote their town and their community, and they began to look at a name change. They had already seen the city of Salem, Massachusetts, what it had experienced down through time, the success that they had had by embracing their name and their past with uh Salem witch massacre trials. So the Salem witch trials had taken place, and we saw Salem adopt their identity and become a town that led them to be Halloween capital of America. North Terrytown began to realize, hey, we've got this history of Washington Irving, and we've got the Headless Horseman. It was the actual the football team had actually gone by that name in 1972 as the North Terrytown Headless Horseman. So leaders began to embrace and say, hey, let's take advantage of this name, and they put the name to a vote. And so according to the CS Monitor newspaper, the vote took place on December 13, 1996, and by a vote of 1304 to 710, and now featuring a 70% turnout, the citizens of North Terrytown decided to rename themselves as Sleepy Hollow. So by all means, there was a little bit of contention with it, 710 votes against it. Some folks were complained about the cost of new signs, repainting government vehicles, just the total rebranding part of it. They were not really too satisfied about, but the votes carried, and on December the 14th, the trustees of the town made it official. Sleepy Hollow is similar to Salem in the fact that I was unable to nail down an actual interview with someone from the school system. I've tried numerous times through different channels, but was unable to secure that. So most of what I found, I found online through the New York High School Athletic Association, through some various research that I've conducted through the CS Monitor newspaper. But I did find out about the football team in 1972 when they began to use the name Headless Horseman. That that season turned out to be a pretty magical season. They go 9-0. They were Section 1 Class A champions, state type state champions, beating John Jay High School by a final of 31-12 in the championship game. And that 31-12 win actually snapped a 28-game winning streak by John Jay. In 2025, by Forschman went 12-2, winning their first Section 1 title since 1978, and they played in the school's first ever state championship game. 2025, they did make it to the state championship. Now in the semifinal game, Braden Richardson carried the ball 27 times for an amazing 446 yards and five touchdowns as they won that game. They would then go on to the next round, to the actual championship game, and unfortunately, they were defeated in that game by Monroe High School in the 34-0 final tally. That game was played at the JMA Wireless Dome in Syracuse. But again, that's not a requirement for the competition. That's just something neat we like to research and find out if they indeed have that, as many communities do. But Sleepy Hollow does not have that headless horseman water tower. What they do have is something that's pretty cool. You have a tradition with the football team where they have a real horse and rider. Before every home game, they have a headless rider on a black horse that leads the team out. And they've been doing that for many years back. And definitely a unique tradition and a pretty cool, cool one at that. Now, honestly, without having a school contact, I'm pretty limited on information. We got to touch base on the actual city, the name change, and the football team, but I don't have much more. My hope is that between Salem and Sleepy Hollow, whoever becomes out as the victor in this matchup, our hope is that we can recircle the circle the wagon again and see if we can make contact with someone at whichever school advances for the round of 16, that we can have somebody who can give us a little more insight to the background of the sleepy, hollow, headless horseman. I sincerely hope you've enjoyed this episode. I hope that you visit the website paintedonthetank.com. Please like and share the podcast. We're on Spotify, iHeart.Anywhere you listen to podcasts at, you can find Painted on the Tank. Please join our Facebook, Paint It on the Tank. Follow the page, engage with us as we vote. You'll be able to currently at this moment, you'll have the option to vote between the Salem Witches or the Sleepy Hollow Headless Horsemen. And to those of you whose team has already advanced, I hope you'll participate. I hope you'll cast a vote for one of these two schools so we can advance them on to the next round. This once again has been an enjoyment for me to host this podcast. And I believe that down the road we're going to see some interesting matchups. We're going to see a lot of fan engagement, especially once we move past the first round and we get into the Sweet 16, the Elite Eight, the Final Four, and of course the big championship matchup. I hope you'll share. Hope you'll listen each week. And I hope you take care and have a good weekend, everyone. Thanks for listening.